A look at the impact and demographics of the now 3-year-old Overlook Townhouses by Baylen Forcier…
Standing on the corner of Holly and Laurel streets looking toward Belvidere Street, you can see a distinct line dividing Oregon Hill.
On the left is the historic working-class neighborhood located just south of VCU’s Monroe Park campus. Some of the homes have been kept nicely through the years, while others have seen better days. Most of the cars out front are more than 10 years old – Toyotas, Hondas, even an old RV.
The right holds the Overlook Townhouses, a new development that has popped up on the southern tip of the neighborhood within the last three years. All the homes are new and well maintained. Even cars are fairly new – Acuras, Audis and a Mustang, none of them more than five years old.
Overlook has won over many Oregon Hill residents who were worried of increased property taxes and changing demographics in the community. They now see the new life that the development has brought to their neighborhood.
The Oregon Hill Neighborhood Association has welcomed the townhouses.
“OHNA and the Overlook residents have made efforts to work together and recognize that it’s still one neighborhood – Oregon Hill,” said Scott Burger, president of the association. Though he feels Overlook is not the perfect solution, he realizes that it could be a lot worse. “Overall, it’s been a success story.”
Success was by no means certain. About five years ago, Oregon Hill faced Ethyl Corp., a chemical company based in Richmond.
According to Burger, Ethyl came in the middle of the night and tore down row houses that had been on the site since the turn of the century. Ethyl had plans to build a gated apartment complex or sell the land to VCU.
“Thankfully, the Oregon Hill Neighborhood Association and city government worked together to dissuade that possibility,” Burger said.
Burger said that a developer named Steve Middleton had the idea to build 85 townhouses on the property. It was a good compromise, though some residents were not too happy at first.
“I used to be able to see the river from my bedroom,” said Mike Myers, who lives on Holly Street across from Overlook. He says that the area was rundown, but now it is nice with a park.
Myers said he understands how people can be worried about higher property values and taxes. His rent has not increased in the past few years, and he said he could tell that Overlook is changing the whole neighborhood around.
Debbie Welch is a real estate agent selling a four-bedroom house in the Overlook community, and she believes the rising property values will be good for Oregon Hill.
“I would be happy,” Welsh said, “if a development was going in that was increasing my property’s value.”
Welch’s client is a former VCU medical student who just graduated and is moving out of the state.
About 25 percent of the residents in Overlook are students, said Timothy Covington, an employee for the real estate firm Exit Elite. Exit Elite is in charge of the development and sells the new houses.
About 40 percent of the residents are young professionals while the remaining 35 percent are retirees, Covington estimates.
The demographics of Overlook worry some older residents in Oregon Hill.
“It’s hard for a lot of people to stomach watching parents from Northern Virginia buy quarter-million-dollar condos for their kids to squat in for four years while going to VCU,” Burger said. He feels that some townhouse residents do not want to become active in the community and help Oregon Hill.
“There is some sniping along class lines about ‘hillbillies vs. yuppies,’” said Burger.
But he added, “Compared to what Oregon Hill was facing, the Overlook condos are a blessing, and I wish Middleton success.”
by Baylen Forcier
I am expecting another article on Oregon Hill from Style magazine soon.
I guess the sociological interest in the neighborhood should come as no surprise considering some of the past studies and articles we have seen.
Just a few thoughts:
I hope everyone realizes that there are exceptions to all stereotypes and while there may be divisiveness in opinions, we are all neighbors, especially when faced by a common threat.
I feel a bit uncomfortable commenting on gentrification since clearly I have been part of it. While I have lived in several rental properties in the Hill since the early 90’s, I did not buy a house till 2002. This pales in comparison to some neighbors, who were born here and go back several generations. Sadly, I have seen some of them forced out by rising property values.
One of the ways that Oregon Hill has coped with gentrification and rising property rates is the neighborhood community development corporation, the Oregon Hill Home Improvement Council. Since 1973, OHHIC has worked to improve the neighborhood and supply affordable, historically sensitive housing. It deserves continued support.
There’s a lot more to the struggle over the Overlook, including children hugging trees, ninjas, newspaper ads, City Council lobbying, and Dominion, but suffice it to say that there’s rich tapestry that goes back to Belvidere, William Byrd II’s plantation and the views from that location.
I was born at 708 S. Pine Street (I was the 4th generation of our family to be born in that house!) and I was so happy to see how the developer remained true to the original row home architecture. I will always regret never having gotten a clipping of the rose bushes my grandfather had planted in the front yard in 1929. But before I could visit Richmond again the homes had been demolished. I live in San Diego now but I will always have a fondness for S. Pine Street and for Oregon Hill. Good job, Overlook! :)
I feel awful, I have such a conflicting view. I bought my house on Laurel St just about ten years ago. I graduated from VCU in 1992, a degree in fine arts. I loved this City then, I am trying to remember what I loved so much, I think it was the people I knew then. I miss the Richmond I once knew, one thing I do not miss is the Old Oregon Hill. Everything changes, I do not want fights like we recently experienced on the first block of Laurel, it had nothing to do with Old Oregon Hill, it did have to do with the things we can not fight, the students are moving into our family blocks. I apologize I am all over the place, I JUST WANT MY HUSBAND AND I TO BE ABLE TO RAISE A HEALTHY BABY IN OUR BEAUTIFUL HOME WITHOUT NEGATIVE NONSENSE. I will do what ever I can to change this community for the better, CALL ME 804 873 4386, I am a snob, I am distressed about all the students, I am mad the community is not better patrolled by the police, I am just mad. I have worked for many years on this home, I want better, and sorry, if that means my home has more value because of the Disney looking homes down the block, I have to take it. My husband and I, at this point, are no longer “middle class”, it sucks, God Bless everyone right now.
While I too agree that things could’ve been much worse with the Ethyl property, I do however think that the overall aesthetic and cohesiveness of the development and neighborhood could’ve been better maintained if a few steps had been taken: the elimination of the interior courts and the addition of proper alleys, individual yards with fences, some detached housing, and generally a less homogenous look. I’m sure the developer would argue that he would’ve lost money by doing that, but as we’ve all seen by the unfinished phase of the development they haven’t exactly hit a home run. That last phase not being developed has nothing to do with the current housing meltdown. It has to do with the condos being grossly overdeveloped in the region and these in particular being grossly overpriced. As far as the cultural impact I feel it will remain a great divide as long as there are people on the Hill with an emotional and familial connection to the homes that were lost in ’97. I have been documenting before and after photos of Oregon Hill on my flickr site at:http://www.flickr.com/photos/deadrichmond/. Scroll down through the sets and you’ll find several devoted to Oregon Hill, Greg Wells